Is Nisuin Biblical or Rabbinic? The Next CEO of Stack OverflowHow can the Rambam say that Kiddushin is a Mitzvah, against the Gemara?How can a convert be a Na'arah Me'orasah?Does anyone hold you can make a stipulation on NisuinWhy use “Kiddushin” instead of biblical “Erusin”?Why in the olden days was there such a long break between Kiddushin & Nisuin?
Is there an equivalent of cd - for cp or mv
How to Implement Deterministic Encryption Safely in .NET
Help understanding this unsettling image of Titan, Epimetheus, and Saturn's rings?
Yu-Gi-Oh cards in Python 3
Small nick on power cord from an electric alarm clock, and copper wiring exposed but intact
How did Beeri the Hittite come up with naming his daughter Yehudit?
Which Pokemon have a special animation when running with them out of their pokeball?
Is there a way to save my career from absolute disaster?
What happened in Rome, when the western empire "fell"?
Calculate the Mean mean of two numbers
Help/tips for a first time writer?
Is it okay to majorly distort historical facts while writing a fiction story?
Is it professional to write unrelated content in an almost-empty email?
Aggressive Under-Indexing and no data for missing index
How to use ReplaceAll on an expression that contains a rule
If Nick Fury and Coulson already knew about aliens (Kree and Skrull) why did they wait until Thor's appearance to start making weapons?
Is fine stranded wire ok for main supply line?
Where do students learn to solve polynomial equations these days?
Getting Stale Gas Out of a Gas Tank w/out Dropping the Tank
What flight has the highest ratio of timezone difference to flight time?
Is French Guiana a (hard) EU border?
What was Carter Burke's job for "the company" in Aliens?
What connection does MS Office have to Netscape Navigator?
How to avoid supervisors with prejudiced views?
Is Nisuin Biblical or Rabbinic?
The Next CEO of Stack OverflowHow can the Rambam say that Kiddushin is a Mitzvah, against the Gemara?How can a convert be a Na'arah Me'orasah?Does anyone hold you can make a stipulation on NisuinWhy use “Kiddushin” instead of biblical “Erusin”?Why in the olden days was there such a long break between Kiddushin & Nisuin?
In exploring the topic of a convert or orphan who is married as a Na'arah, I stumbled upon a surprising piece in the Beis Shmuel:
...הואיל קידושין דאורייתא הם ונישואין אינם מדאורייתא...
...since Kiddushin is from the Torah, but Nisuin is not from the Torah...
While it's obvious that Kiddushin is from the Torah, I was surprised to see an opinion that Nisuin is not from the Torah, as I had never heard of such a thing before. Indeed, it's the Rambam's opinion that Kiddushin and Nisuin are two parts of the same Biblical mitzvah (as discussed here).
- What is the Beis Shmuel's source for this assertion?
- Whatever the answer to #1, how does the Rambam address it?
marriage
add a comment |
In exploring the topic of a convert or orphan who is married as a Na'arah, I stumbled upon a surprising piece in the Beis Shmuel:
...הואיל קידושין דאורייתא הם ונישואין אינם מדאורייתא...
...since Kiddushin is from the Torah, but Nisuin is not from the Torah...
While it's obvious that Kiddushin is from the Torah, I was surprised to see an opinion that Nisuin is not from the Torah, as I had never heard of such a thing before. Indeed, it's the Rambam's opinion that Kiddushin and Nisuin are two parts of the same Biblical mitzvah (as discussed here).
- What is the Beis Shmuel's source for this assertion?
- Whatever the answer to #1, how does the Rambam address it?
marriage
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago
add a comment |
In exploring the topic of a convert or orphan who is married as a Na'arah, I stumbled upon a surprising piece in the Beis Shmuel:
...הואיל קידושין דאורייתא הם ונישואין אינם מדאורייתא...
...since Kiddushin is from the Torah, but Nisuin is not from the Torah...
While it's obvious that Kiddushin is from the Torah, I was surprised to see an opinion that Nisuin is not from the Torah, as I had never heard of such a thing before. Indeed, it's the Rambam's opinion that Kiddushin and Nisuin are two parts of the same Biblical mitzvah (as discussed here).
- What is the Beis Shmuel's source for this assertion?
- Whatever the answer to #1, how does the Rambam address it?
marriage
In exploring the topic of a convert or orphan who is married as a Na'arah, I stumbled upon a surprising piece in the Beis Shmuel:
...הואיל קידושין דאורייתא הם ונישואין אינם מדאורייתא...
...since Kiddushin is from the Torah, but Nisuin is not from the Torah...
While it's obvious that Kiddushin is from the Torah, I was surprised to see an opinion that Nisuin is not from the Torah, as I had never heard of such a thing before. Indeed, it's the Rambam's opinion that Kiddushin and Nisuin are two parts of the same Biblical mitzvah (as discussed here).
- What is the Beis Shmuel's source for this assertion?
- Whatever the answer to #1, how does the Rambam address it?
marriage
marriage
asked 2 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
16.6k12587
16.6k12587
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago
add a comment |
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
The Beis Shmuel does not mean to say that in general nisuin is Rabbinical. He is referring to the Mordechai which the Rema on which he is commenting refers to, which explains that since the father is dead, the nisuin in this case is Rabbinical, while the kiddushin performed before the father died is Biblical. Language of the Mordechai, תקטז:
כי אמרו אפילו ישאנה בעודה קטנה כיון שקידושיה היו קידושין דאורייתא ונשואין דרבנן דליכא אב למימסר לחופה הרי היא כביאת זנות...
[Some Rabbis] said that even if he marries her while she is still a minor, since the kiddushin was Biblical and the nissuin Rabbinical, as there is no father to transfer her to the chuppah, it will be like zenus...
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The Beis Shmuel does not mean to say that in general nisuin is Rabbinical. He is referring to the Mordechai which the Rema on which he is commenting refers to, which explains that since the father is dead, the nisuin in this case is Rabbinical, while the kiddushin performed before the father died is Biblical. Language of the Mordechai, תקטז:
כי אמרו אפילו ישאנה בעודה קטנה כיון שקידושיה היו קידושין דאורייתא ונשואין דרבנן דליכא אב למימסר לחופה הרי היא כביאת זנות...
[Some Rabbis] said that even if he marries her while she is still a minor, since the kiddushin was Biblical and the nissuin Rabbinical, as there is no father to transfer her to the chuppah, it will be like zenus...
add a comment |
The Beis Shmuel does not mean to say that in general nisuin is Rabbinical. He is referring to the Mordechai which the Rema on which he is commenting refers to, which explains that since the father is dead, the nisuin in this case is Rabbinical, while the kiddushin performed before the father died is Biblical. Language of the Mordechai, תקטז:
כי אמרו אפילו ישאנה בעודה קטנה כיון שקידושיה היו קידושין דאורייתא ונשואין דרבנן דליכא אב למימסר לחופה הרי היא כביאת זנות...
[Some Rabbis] said that even if he marries her while she is still a minor, since the kiddushin was Biblical and the nissuin Rabbinical, as there is no father to transfer her to the chuppah, it will be like zenus...
add a comment |
The Beis Shmuel does not mean to say that in general nisuin is Rabbinical. He is referring to the Mordechai which the Rema on which he is commenting refers to, which explains that since the father is dead, the nisuin in this case is Rabbinical, while the kiddushin performed before the father died is Biblical. Language of the Mordechai, תקטז:
כי אמרו אפילו ישאנה בעודה קטנה כיון שקידושיה היו קידושין דאורייתא ונשואין דרבנן דליכא אב למימסר לחופה הרי היא כביאת זנות...
[Some Rabbis] said that even if he marries her while she is still a minor, since the kiddushin was Biblical and the nissuin Rabbinical, as there is no father to transfer her to the chuppah, it will be like zenus...
The Beis Shmuel does not mean to say that in general nisuin is Rabbinical. He is referring to the Mordechai which the Rema on which he is commenting refers to, which explains that since the father is dead, the nisuin in this case is Rabbinical, while the kiddushin performed before the father died is Biblical. Language of the Mordechai, תקטז:
כי אמרו אפילו ישאנה בעודה קטנה כיון שקידושיה היו קידושין דאורייתא ונשואין דרבנן דליכא אב למימסר לחופה הרי היא כביאת זנות...
[Some Rabbis] said that even if he marries her while she is still a minor, since the kiddushin was Biblical and the nissuin Rabbinical, as there is no father to transfer her to the chuppah, it will be like zenus...
edited 15 mins ago
answered 20 mins ago
Y e zY e z
46k375208
46k375208
add a comment |
add a comment |
Is this then two questions?
– Dr. Shmuel
1 hour ago
@Dr.Shmuel Yes, but it's two heavily related questions.
– DonielF
1 hour ago